Diary of a Horseshoer #5: Why Licensing ISN'T Good
Journal Entry:
Mon Jul 27, 2009, 6:26 PM
- Mood:
Irritated - Listening to: an archeology documentary
- Reading: Proverbs
- Watching: my headache start
- Playing: with horses
- Eating: steak and corn on the cob
- Drinking: water
The American Farrier Association is currently pushing for farrier licensing against the wishes of most members. Some people seem to think that licensing will improve the standards of farrier work and reassure the horse owning public about the farriers out there.
Mind you, there is already a voluntary certification system in place for farriers. Any farrier who wants to can take the voluntary test and add that certification to his or her resume.
In addition, surveys of the horse owning public shows that certification and/or licensing is NOT their first concern when they are searching for a farrier. Things like "caring about my horse" and "keeping appointments on time" tend to be far more important to the average horse owner.
Furthermore, no matter what any individual thinks about their horse, the bare fact is that horses are private property. Yes, to those of us who work with them every day, they are individual beings. We come to recognize them as personalities in their own right. Legally speaking, however, they belong to us.
When does the government get the right to tell a private property owner who they can hire to do what to their property? I know they already do to a large degree, but that still doesn't make it right.
In addition, horseshoeing is an art. It CANNOT be standardized, it often cannot be scientifically studied, and results can often not be reproduced from horse to horse. Each horse is different, and each shoeing job is different. In order to create a "test" there will have to be some very arbitrary standards. The ability to hit a completely arbitrary standard on a given day does not make either a good artist OR a good horseshoer.
Licensing will happen because there are people out there who are constitutionally incapable of failing to interfere. There's not much I can do about it, but I can be publicly unhappy about it.
Thank you for putting up with my rant, and I'll try to get back to happier subjects the next time.
Nice photos...I had to write back. I once thought I might take up horseshoeing....thought better of it when I came to my senses and realized I barely knew the front of the horse from the rear... A few years later, I started in on blacksmithing instead. Glad you like the copper roses. The difference in the patinas is the alloy of the copper. I was astonished when I could not get a red out of a large sheet of copper. I thought it was something I was doing for quite a while. Ultimately, I was able to see an application. While I like the red best, others prefer the more earthy colors. have a good time with your art, Smitty
Thanks for your comments on my photos. I took up horseshoeing originally because I love horses, have ridden them since I was five, and eventually realized that I'd never be happy without them. It helps that I was also fascinated by forging and metalwork since I found out that individuals could do it at the RenFaire when I was fourteen.
I'm nowhere near as good as you at metalworking yet, though I'm working on that. I expect to spend ten years at it before I get remotely where I want to be. I work with a gas forge and a 100 lb anvil, and right now I'm working on getting my forge welding right. Sometimes my master farrier lets me work in his shop with his 250 lb anvil, but that's a luxury. We're usually busy with show horses or therapeutic cases, so I don't have as much time to practice as I'd like. However, I'll definitely be watching your work and maybe bugging you for details if that's ok.
--
The future of society lies in the hands of the creatively maladjusted. - Martin Luther King Jr.
Webmaster of and assistant to the Arkansas Horseshoeing School
--
[link]
--
The future of society lies in the hands of the creatively maladjusted. - Martin Luther King Jr.
Webmaster of and assistant to the Arkansas Horseshoeing School
--
[link]
--
The future of society lies in the hands of the creatively maladjusted. - Martin Luther King Jr.
Webmaster of and assistant to the Arkansas Horseshoeing School
Previous Page123Next Page